MBC News file photo
A historic building in downtown Simcoe will remain protected after Norfolk County council voted against removing its heritage designation following strong public opposition.
The decision reverses council’s April vote to begin the de-designation process for the 116-year-old building at 45 Peel Street, located at the corner of Peel and Kent streets. The building was originally constructed as Simcoe’s post office and customs office before later serving as town hall offices and housing the Bank of Montreal. It was also the longtime office of renowned architect Carlos Ventin.
Owner Harish Rajput said the property is losing money due to high maintenance costs, expensive insurance and difficulty attracting buyers or tenants. He told council the building has become increasingly costly to own, despite knowing about the heritage designation when he purchased it. The property had previously been listed for sale before being offered for lease.
County staff recommended keeping the designation, noting the building’s strong construction and significant architectural features, including its original windows, doorways and roofline. The exterior has been protected under the Ontario Heritage Act since 1981, while the interior is not covered by the designation.
The proposal sparked significant community interest. During the required public consultation period, Norfolk County received more than 50 letters objecting to removing the designation and just two letters supporting it.
Heritage advocates told council the building has become even more significant over time because of its connection to Carlos Ventin, whose architectural work can be found throughout Norfolk County and across Ontario. The Norfolk Historical Society also warned that removing the designation could create a precedent for other heritage buildings in the community.
After hearing from residents, heritage supporters and the property owner, council voted to reject the de-designation request, ensuring the historic building will continue to be protected under the Ontario Heritage Act.
